• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
    • Contact
    • Press & Partnerships
    • Copyright/Disclosure
    • Links/Parties/Giveaways
    • HOI Friends
      • Toni Roberts
      • Tauni Everett
      • Tammy Mitchell
      • Randi Dukes
      • Michelle Stewart
      • Mariah Leeson
      • Mandy Beyeler
      • Lindi Haws
      • Kim Byers
      • Ashley Johnston
      • House of Ideas
  • Videos
  • SHOP

Design Dazzle

Inspiration for kids rooms, baby nurseries, and kids parties

  • My Home
    • Home Tour
    • Christmas Home Tour
  • My Projects
    • My Projects
    • Companies I Have Worked With
    • Michaels Makers
  • DIY/Decor
    • top tutorials
  • crafts
  • celebrations
    • parties
    • christmas
    • halloween
    • thanksgiving/fall
    • New Year’s
    • Valentine’s Day
    • St. Patrick’s Day
    • Easter/Spring
    • mother’s day
    • father’s day
    • patriotic
    • School/Teacher/Graduation
    • Gift Ideas
    • weddings
    • best ideas
  • Recipes
    • Meals
    • Instant Pot/Crock Pot
    • Desserts
    • Treats & Snacks
  • travel
  • free printables
  • Lifestyle
    • organization
    • Preparedness
    • Healthy Living
  • kids
    • kids parties
    • kids rooms
      • cool bedroom ideas
    • summer camp/crafts
You are here: Home / celebrations / valentine's / Nutter Butter Cookie Hearts

February 10, 2019

Nutter Butter Cookie Hearts

Oh my these Nutter Butter cookie hearts will melt your heart!

I love how clever they were created and that they are super quick and easy too!

One exciting part is that theses can be made to use by themselves or placed on top of cupcakes (as shown in the images below)!

They’re a perfect party treats for your Valentine’s day party or basically for any occasion, OR just an afternoon snack in an ordinary day just to satisfy your sweet tooth or the kids’ cravings!

Oh my these Nutter Butter cookie hearts will melt your heart! Quick and easy Valentine's Day treat that is so fun to make! #valentinesday - Design Dazzle

Ingredients:

12 cupcakes (your favorite)

1 cup chocolate icing (your favorite)

12 Nutter Butter cookies

Pink candy melts

Pink sugar sprinkles

Valentine’s Day sprinkles

Instructions:

1. Using a serrated knife, cut each Nutter Butter cookie in half diagonally across the short-middle using a sawing motion.

Use a pastry brush to remove any loose crumbs.

Oh my these Nutter Butter cookie hearts will melt your heart! I love how clever they were created and that they are super quick and easy too! Check them out! - Design Dazzle

Oh my these Nutter Butter cookie hearts will melt your heart! I love how clever they were created and that they are super quick and easy too! Check them out! - Design Dazzle

2. Melt candy coating according to package directions.

If candy melts are too thick, add 1 tablespoon of shortening or coconut oil and stir to combine.

Do not add water or any water-based product (such as food coloring) or the candy melts will seize and not be usable.

Oh my these Nutter Butter cookie hearts will melt your heart! I love how clever they were created and that they are super quick and easy too! Check them out! - Design Dazzle

3. Prepare a baking sheet or flat surface with waxed paper.

4. To create the heart-shaped Nutter Butters, you have two options.

(1) Use the candy melts as a glue to attach two pieces of Nutter Butter cookie together with one cookie flipped to create a heart shape when pressed together.

Allow cookie to set completely before covering with additional candy melts.

Oh my these Nutter Butter cookie hearts will melt your heart! I love how clever they were created and that they are super quick and easy too! Check them out! - Design Dazzle

Oh my these Nutter Butter cookie hearts will melt your heart! I love how clever they were created and that they are super quick and easy too! Check them out! - Design Dazzle

(2) Dip each half cookie in candy melts and allow excess to drip back into the bowl.

Press two coated cookie pieces together with one cookie flipped to create a heart shape.

Place on waxed paper.

Oh my these Nutter Butter cookie hearts will melt your heart! I love how clever they were created and that they are super quick and easy too! Check them out! - Design Dazzle

Oh my these Nutter Butter cookie hearts will melt your heart! I love how clever they were created and that they are super quick and easy too! Check them out! - Design Dazzle

 

5. Immediately after coating the cookies, sprinkle with pink sugar sprinkles.

Allow to dry completely.

Oh my these Nutter Butter cookie hearts will melt your heart! I love how clever they were created and that they are super quick and easy too! Check them out! - Design Dazzle

6. To create the cupcakes, decorate cupcakes with icing and drop sprinkles over the icing.

Gently press one Nutter Butter heart into the icing of each cupcake.

Oh my these Nutter Butter cookie hearts will melt your heart! I love how clever they were created and that they are super quick and easy too! Check them out! - Design Dazzle

7. For best results, refrigerate until ready to serve.

Oh my these Nutter Butter cookie hearts will melt your heart! I love how clever they were created and that they are super quick and easy too! Check them out! - Design Dazzle

Oh my these Nutter Butter cookie hearts will melt your heart! I love how clever they were created and that they are super quick and easy too! Check them out! - Design Dazzle

Nutter butter heart cupcakes 11
Print

Nutter Butter Cookie Hearts

Quick and easy party treats for Valentine's day or an afternoon snack for any day any time of the year!  

Ingredients

  • 12 cupcakes your favorite
  • 1 cup chocolate icing your favorite
  • 12 Nutter Butter cookies
  • Pink candy melts
  • Pink sugar sprinkles
  • Valentine’s Day sprinkles

Instructions

  1. Using a serrated knife, cut each Nutter Butter cookie in half diagonally across the short-middle using a sawing motion.

    Use a pastry brush to remove any loose crumbs.

  2. Melt candy coating according to package directions.

    If candy melts are too thick, add 1 tablespoon of shortening or coconut oil and stir to combine.

    Do not add water or any water-based product (such as food coloring) or the candy melts will seize and not be usable.

  3. Prepare a baking sheet or flat surface with waxed paper.

  4. To create the heart-shaped Nutter Butters, you have two options. (1) Use the candy melts as a glue to attach two pieces of Nutter Butter cookie together with one cookie flipped to create a heart shape when pressed together. Allow cookie to set completely before covering with additional candy melts. 

    (2) Dip each half cookie in candy melts and allow excess to drip back into the bowl. Press two coated cookie pieces together with one cookie flipped to create a heart shape. Place on waxed paper.

  5. Immediately after coating the cookies, sprinkle with pink sugar sprinkles. Allow to dry completely.

  6.  To create the cupcakes, decorate cupcakes with icing and drop sprinkles over the icing. Gently press one Nutter Butter heart into the icing of each cupcake.

  7. For best results, refrigerate until ready to serve.

If you are looking for more fun and cute Valentine’s day treat ideas, check out these monster heart brownies!

Monster heart brownies collage 1

Here are some of things you need to make your own Nutter Butter cookie hearts!

 

Signature toni jpg 300x115 1

Don't Miss Out!

Thank you for subscribing to the Design Dazzle newsletter. You will soon receive an email asking you to confirm your subscription. Make sure to clink the link in the email!

Don't Miss Out!

Enjoy DIY, crafts, home decor ideas, free printables, travel tips and more!

Disclaimer

This post may contain affiliate links, which means that if you click on a product link, we may receive a commission (at no extra cost to you). See my full disclosure for further details.

Reader Interactions

Primary Sidebar

Img 0422

Hi, I’m Toni! Welcome to my blog Design Dazzle. I love being a designer, DIYer, traveler, crafter, holiday lover, and memory maker. Read more.

Toni Roberts is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com

DesignDazzle.com is protected by copyright laws. DO NOT distribute or copy the content or share multiple images or collage images without written permission. You can use ONE Design Dazzle image only if there is a link back to DesignDazzle.com. DO NOT edit, crop, or remove watermarks from any image. Please contact me at toni@designdazzle.com with any questions.

About | Contact Us | Privacy and Legal

© 2017 Design Dazzle · All Rights Reserved. | Hosted by House of Ideas